Re: [Fwd: Re: Why?]



Owen Heisler wrote:
<snip>
This all seems to be about questions in the installer, but all the
installer really does (at least for me) is set up a minimal Debian
system. I think the tasksel that the installer uses (that's it, right?)
is so simple that it is useless, but I don't want to use it anyway. I
will use my preferred method of package management to install other junk
later. For the newbie, this would be aptitude ran from base-config.

My opinion is that the installer should be kept simple, excluding
package selection. The installer sets up a minimal system, and other
packages are added later using other software. /This/ software can be
set up to be newbie-friendly. Their are way too many options for
packages for any of it to be incorporated into the installer.

$0.02 from Owen
What is the "Minimal System"?
When I install Debian, I tend to install just as little as I can, then
back out of hte install as soon as I can - this, to me, is the ideal
inital install of Debian - though I do tend to setup servers.

Other people feel that the _everything_ should be installed (Which, to
their annoyance, just isn't possible on Debian), and between these two
extremes, we have all kinds of middle grounds.

Some are very happy with the "Minimal" system that Ubuntu setups, others
like tasksel, - the point I'm making is that what is "Minimal" is very
hard to get more than two people to agree on.

Personally, I love the minimal installation of Debian for servers - but
lately I've prefered the "minimal" installation of Ubuntu for my
desktops - the needs are different. (Having said that, I'm returning to
Debian - I'm just too used to it.)


--
To UNSUBSCRIBE, email to debian-user-REQUEST@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
with a subject of "unsubscribe". Trouble? Contact listmaster@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx



Relevant Pages

  • Re: Network installation from a centralixed server
    ... Woody's standard installer is a pain and not to be recommended. ... Anaconda to Debian, and Anaconda beats the new debian-installer hands down* ... FAI is a debian package. ... of interest, plus seven CDs of Woody and a dozen or so of Sarge, plus ...
    (Debian-User)
  • Re: [Debian-User] re: Network Install
    ... download binariy and source files one at a time from over the internet. ... Apparently, when the package is ... I need a Debian system up and running (which I don't ... I take it that the network installer puts ...
    (Debian-User)
  • Re: Bootloader
    ... load the Debian based stuff. ... # array will desync and will not let you boot your system. ... ## should update-grub add savedefault to the default options ... # This entry automatically added by the Debian installer for a non-linux OS ...
    (alt.os.linux)
  • Re: redhat vs debian
    ... routine while I was installing Debian for the first time just 3 days ago. ... installer has brought same to all Linux users/programmers. ... > help screens was a shocking reminder of the old dos character based ... > that some mice are USB. ...
    (linux.redhat)
  • AW: branding debian releases
    ... getting newbies into Linux, especially Debian. ... careful :-) And as much as I hate M$ the installer is pretty nice. ... I always found dselect very straightforward.. ... Okay then your wife's more clever then me, the first time I tried to isntall ...
    (Debian-User)