Re: Vfat or NTFS?

The 4 Gig max filesize of vfat makes it unusable for me.

I used ntfs-3g for more than a year on 4 different HDD, all around 1 TB and had no
problems with stability, data loss or any problems at all.
Performance is ok, but not very fast.
I got rates of max. 15 MByte/s on Encrypted USB 2.0 Truecrypt HDDs.

An Windows ext2/ext3 is also an alternative: http://www.fs-driver.org/
But there are some limitations. Check their FAQ.

I would the the fuse ntfs-3g driver, so you don't have to alter your windows installation
and it is usable at a friend's windows pc.

One problem I encountered with ntfs-3g is that it consumes 99% CPU and the transfer rate
drops below 1 MByte if you got only 10% space left and the data is fragmented.
Keep that in mind.

One contra for ext3 is that is uses 10+ GByte more space for the filesystem and journal
(on 1 TB Drives).

Sebastian



On Sunday 07 March 2010 19:50:12 Russell Gadd wrote:
I've been using Vfat for data partitions which I can access from both Linux
and Windows (multibooted). Recently I added another hard drive formatted
NTFS and have had no trouble getting Lenny to use it.

I am wondering now whether to convert my Vfat partitions to NTFS as there
are some advantages. For example I recently forgot about the 4GB file
restriction of Vfat when trying to download a DVD iso - it got to 4GB then
gave up so I had to redownload again to the NTFS volume. I suspect NTFS is
more reliable at least in Windows. Are there any potential issues in Linux
- e.g. reliability / speed.

Should I go NTFS now for my data files? (keeping the main Lenny root
filesystem on an ext3 partition).


--
To UNSUBSCRIBE, email to debian-user-REQUEST@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
with a subject of "unsubscribe". Trouble? Contact listmaster@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
Archive: http://lists.debian.org/201003072357.45746.sebastian.weisgerber@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

Relevant Pages

  • Re: Share/Freeware to see FBSD from Win_XPproSP1?
    ... Windows XP can only read FAT 12/16/32 and NTFS. ... To unsubscribe, ...
    (freebsd-questions)
  • Vfat or NTFS?
    ... I've been using Vfat for data partitions which I can access from both Linux ... NTFS and have had no trouble getting Lenny to use it. ... more reliable at least in Windows. ...
    (Debian-User)
  • Re: Error reading pen drive
    ... When you do not have a partition table, Windows does not know what ... as FAT, VFAT, or NTFS you will be limited in where you can use it. ...
    (Fedora)
  • Operation not permitted on firewire/NTFS external HD
    ... When I try and create/delete any files or directories under /mnt/ext1, ... placed under windows xp). ... I can do these operations fine on a vfat ... To unsubscribe: http://www.redhat.com/mailman/listinfo/fedora-list ...
    (Fedora)
  • Re: how to format a usb hard drive for use with linux or windows
    ... You need to make sure it's either vfat or NTFS in general. ... supports these two Windowsy filesystem reasonably well, ... wont do any Linux filesystem out of the box. ...
    (Ubuntu)