Re: simple ln question

On Sat, Aug 25, 2007 at 09:26:46PM +0000, tony.chamberlain@xxxxxxxxx wrote:
I have a script that occasionally does something like this

ln file1 file2

that makes it so the contents of file1 are the same as of file2, and if you change the contents of 1, the other
changes accordingly.

No, that's not what it does. What it does is makes TWO directory entries
both pointing to the same file. There is ONLY ONE FILE. So obviously when
you change the file it is changed regardless of which directory entry you
use to access it, again: because there is only one file.


I can slo do this

ln -s file1 files

which is somewhat similar, but of course works over file systems and file2 is really just a symbolic link to file1.

Right. Again, there is only one file. While symbolic (aka soft) links are
not the same as "hard" links, the fact remains that there is only one
file even though there are multiple ways to access it.


Anyway, sometimes I want to undo what I did, but I can't say

unlink file2

In the case of a hard link (your first example) you can remove either file1
or file2 and all it does is remove the extra directory entry that points
to that file. The file is untouched.

With the symbolic link, one of the items is the real file, and the other
is an "indirection" that points to it. You can remove the indirection
(i.e., the soft link) and the file remains. But if you remove the file
then the link, which remains, is a "dangling" link, i.e., the thing it
points to has gone missing.


because that will remove file2. I just want it , so that the files are still the same but if I change one, the other will
not change (i.e., inodes are different but diff shows no differences). I can't see any flags for ln. Anyone have
any idea? I know it can be fudged like

sed -i 's/ / /g' file1

but this is kind of fudging, and it may not work on binary files.

If you want two copies of a file, such that you could modify one with
modifying the other, then you need to copy the original (man cp), not
link it. That's not what ln is for.


another question. If you have a file FILE1 can you find everything that is linked
to it? say you have

ln -s /this/is/filesystem/1/FILE1 /filesystem/2/FILE2

given FILE1 can you find FILE2? It is pretty easy the other way around (readlink FILE2) but that does


ls -i foobar

prints the inode number for the file foobar.

ls -l foobar

will print, among other things, the number of hard links to a file. once
you know which inode the file uses, you can find all files using that
inode like this:

find . -inum 231526 -exec ls -il {} \;

where (in this example) 231526 is the inode for the file in question.

not work for FILE1. Also if "ln" instead of "ln -s" you cannot do it.

I guess you could do ls -i /this/is/filesystem/1/FILE1, get the inum and then do a

find / -type f -inum x # Whatever the inum is

As shown above.

--
---- Fred Smith -- fredex@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx -----------------------------
"For him who is able to keep you from falling and to present you before his
glorious presence without fault and with great joy--to the only God our Savior
be glory, majesty, power and authority, through Jesus Christ our Lord, before
all ages, now and forevermore! Amen."
----------------------------- Jude 1:24,25 (niv) -----------------------------

Attachment: pgpSqwoGmJlxf.pgp
Description: PGP signature

--
fedora-list mailing list
fedora-list@xxxxxxxxxx
To unsubscribe: https://www.redhat.com/mailman/listinfo/fedora-list

Relevant Pages

  • Re: Re-linking hard links
    ... duplicates to point to a single inode. ... For instance if file1 has ... file2 and the pathnames of file1 and file2. ... You cannot have "files with hardlinks to each other". ...
    (comp.os.linux.misc)
  • RE: data conundrum
    ... in your spens you'll want to keep field names consistent. ... the specs will be the most tedious, but once theyr're done once they're done. ... in other words, you have file1, file2, file3..... ...
    (microsoft.public.access.externaldata)
  • RE: data conundrum
    ... let's say file1 looks like this: ... and let's say file2 looks like this: ... then you will probably have to create import specs for all 100 ... create from the .csv files) as opposed to using a form, ...
    (microsoft.public.access.externaldata)
  • Re: Need Help
    ... eg: file1, file2, file3 etc ... into, max 5-6, chunk files and then loading these chunk files into ...
    (comp.unix.shell)
  • Re: egrep question
    ... I personally would not use grep but awk instead, especially if file1 and file2 ... If you use egrep, ... Tom Sawyer in file2. ...
    (AIX-L)