Re: Possible GPL Violation

From: Måns Rullgård (
Date: 05/30/05

  • Next message: Stefano Rivoir: "Re: 2.6.12-rc5-mm1"
    Date:	Mon, 30 May 2005 15:50:06 +0200

    Carlos Silva <> writes:

    > Hi,
    > the company that i work for is going to buy a pair of Panda
    > Gatedefenders 8200 that are linux based. To start, they never told us or
    > mention on their site (as far as i searched) the use of linux in their
    > product. Another thing is that they don't give us root access nor any
    > other type of local access to the box besides the http page the
    > appliance have to be managed.

    There's no requirement to give you full access to the machine. If you
    don't like that, don't buy it.

    > The thing is that i asked for the kernel source they use in the
    > system and they said they can't give it since they have some
    > proprietary code in it, as far as i understood.

    If they use some modules of their own writing, the general agreement
    seems to be that they don't need to release the source code to those.
    They should still give you the kernel source they used, along with any
    patches they may have applied.

    > I really don't know the proper way to report a GPL violation so i
    > thought this was a good place. If there is any question please feel
    > free to ask, i'll do my best to answer it.

    I'm having some problems myself with an STB manufacturer (Amino). The
    STB is running a Busybox/Montavista Linux of some kind, and I need to
    make some changes. To do this, they tell me I need the SDK, which is
    only available under NDA, and then only after purchasing a support
    contract for an ungodly number of dollars. Somehow, I get the feeling
    they are on thin ice here.

    Måns Rullgård
    To unsubscribe from this list: send the line "unsubscribe linux-kernel" in
    the body of a message to
    More majordomo info at
    Please read the FAQ at

  • Next message: Stefano Rivoir: "Re: 2.6.12-rc5-mm1"

    Relevant Pages

    • Table of mmap PROT_* implementations by architecture
      ... From a study of Linux 2.6.5 source code, ... - The PaX security patch simulates fine-grained exec permission. ... send the line "unsubscribe linux-kernel" in ...
    • Re: Video editing in Linux?
      ... whatever you would want, i would have to first get linux installed, ... It is totally viable that you could modify the source code out there ... in the same way that Windows security gets ... i doubt your cpu even hits 10% of its potential ...
    • Re: Building an assembler from scratch
      ... Some proprietary software has been released as FOSS software after the ... want source code 99.99% of the time. ... You cannot say that about Linux. ... OpenGL 3.2 deprecated some features (API calls); ...
    • Re: Rimax Linux DVD/DivX player firwmare source code
      ... The firmware I have seems to be based on linux v2.4.17-uc0, ... and "KHWL.O" by Emmanuel Michon and Fabrice Gautier of Sigma Designs. ... > The sigma designs reference system source code is here ... send the line "unsubscribe linux-kernel" in ...
    • RE: possible GPL violation by Sigma Designs
      ... I purchased a Liteon LVD2001 DVD player which uses this Sigma EM8500 chipset ... and firmware running Linux. ... devices in the PCMCIA slot of this DVD player but source code for their ... drivers (GPL status for these is unknown), ...