Re: GPLv3 Position Statement

James Bottomley <James.Bottomley@xxxxxxxxxxxx> writes:
I'm asserting that producing something (an appliance say, or a PCI
card) that runs linux to achieve its function is a "use" (an act of
running the program) within the meaning of GPLv2 clause 0. Selling
the Box (or card, or whatever) also becomes a distribution.

The vendor did many acts covered by copyright law (taking US copyright
law here), and it's important to distinguish the effects of the
license on each act:

1. Use: Vendor runs Linux on prototype hardware to see where it fails
to boot, in order to write new drivers. The GPL places no
restriction on this act, and probably cannot do so since US
copyright law doesn't cover running a program.

2. Prepare a derivative work: Vendor writes drivers for their
hardware, builds a new Linux kernel. The GPLv2 places no
restriction on this act. The GPLv3 restricts this act a bit in the
patent retaliation clause.

3. Use the derivative work: Vendor tests (runs) the modified Linux.
There are no restrictions placed by the GPL (v2 or v3). If you can
make the derivative work (e.g. don't fall foul of the
patent-retaliation clause in GPLv3), then you can use it how you
want.

4. Distribute the derivative work: Vendor sells the hardware with
embedded Linux. Now the GPL places restrictions. v2 says that if
you distribute, you must make source code available and (if I
understand Alan Cox's argument correctly) make the installation
keys available. v3 tightens the installation-keys requirement.
But it's not a use restriction.

However I claim that, the GPLv3 requirement that you be able to "execute
modified versions from source code in the recommended or principal
context of use" does constitute an end use restriction on the embedded
system because the appliance (or card, or whatever) must be designed in
such a way as to allow this.

Not necessarily. If the vendor makes devices for internal use, they
are not distributing the kernel, so no GPL requirements (except
perhaps the GPLv3 patent retaliation clause) are triggered. Only when
they distribute does the GPL place requirements on what they must do:
provide source code and installation keys. So it's not the use that
is restricted (they can do what they like 'at home'), only the
distribution.

Regards,
-Sanjoy

`Never underestimate the evil of which men of power are capable.'
--Bertrand Russell, _War Crimes in Vietnam_, chapter 1.
-
To unsubscribe from this list: send the line "unsubscribe linux-kernel" in
the body of a message to majordomo@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
More majordomo info at http://vger.kernel.org/majordomo-info.html
Please read the FAQ at http://www.tux.org/lkml/

Relevant Pages

  • Re: can one build commercial applications with latest gnat and other licenses related questions...
    ... I stopped reading after "is 10% of the cost of an ACT" ... The Linux version is unaccountably much more. ... $12000 for 10 developer seats, ... We have been talking about Aonix. ...
    (comp.lang.ada)
  • Re: Bad phish! BAD, BAD, PHISH!
    ... of phishing attacks since about Christmas, and we have an outside security ... and act to get a site killed as soon as a new phishing run starts. ... I don't understand how an "outside security vendor" can monitor ...
    (alt.marketing.online.ebay)
  • Re: the ultimate operating system
    ... If it look like Windows but don't act like no Windows, ... If it do be look like Linux but don't act like Linux, ... Anything that provides a common GUI has to act like that GUI in ...
    (comp.programming)
  • Re: Overheard on the scanner
    ... Act of Parliament, obtained under the general procedures of a private ... building railways, enclosures, and sewage systems. ... clause which dissolved his own marriage. ...
    (rec.arts.sf.fandom)
  • Re: My Copyright- @2008
    ... Well it is a class act technology and here is the basic logical drive. ... A t variable as a time clause for all things considered appear the ... A first noun is ALWAYS a future relative! ... All knowledge as a rule can then be database searchable. ...
    (sci.physics)