Re: AppArmor FAQ

James Morris wrote:
On Tue, 17 Apr 2007, Alan Cox wrote:

I'm not sure if AppArmor can be made good security for the general case,
but it is a model that works in the limited http environment
(eg .htaccess) and is something people can play with and hack on and may
be possible to configure to be very secure.

Perhaps -- until your httpd is compromised via a buffer overflow or simply misbehaves due to a software or configuration flaw, then the assumptions being made about its use of pathnames and their security properties are out the window.

Without security labeling of the objects being accessed, you can't protect against software flaws, which has been a pretty fundamental and widely understood requirement in general computing for at least a decade.

And that's why apparmor should be implemented as a stackable file system with a container mechanism, and I implemented such a thing back in 2003, albiet mostly just proof of concept and a horribly written paper (it was my first), so never got published beyond a tech report.

http://www.ncl.cs.columbia.edu/publications/cucs-005-04.pdf

Basically, on disk labeling is not necessarily an easy mechanism for app armor type things as it's not easy to use and different applications have different requirements so end up w/ multiple labels attached that are difficult to understand. That's why app armor's path based rules are nice, each app has its own set of rules, and one can easily eyeball what rules apply to each app, as well as easily change it. However, since apparmor has no conception of the actual file system, so it's broken by design.

If on the other hand it was implemented as a stackable file system, each fs object would be labeled. The same underlying FS could be used by multiple distinct applications w/ distinct security issues, and one could even combine it with something like unionfs to give each domain a separate writable area, avoiding the "output file issue", where output filess could be used to attack the system.
-
To unsubscribe from this list: send the line "unsubscribe linux-kernel" in
the body of a message to majordomo@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
More majordomo info at http://vger.kernel.org/majordomo-info.html
Please read the FAQ at http://www.tux.org/lkml/

Relevant Pages

  • Re: Interplatform (interprocess, interlanguage) communication
    ... If I'm using XML at all, and JAXB suits, I'll use JAXB. ... one can wonder though, what really would be the gain of using XML syntax in many such cases, vs the typical "relative niceness" of a line oriented format. ... typically I don't deal a whole lot with anything "security ... a 3rd party could somehow break the app and get control of the users' OS ...
    (comp.lang.java.programmer)
  • [UNIX] Buffer Overflow in ISO9660 File System Component of Linux Kernel
    ... Get your security news from a reliable source. ... The Linux kernel performs no length checking on ... symbolic links stored on an ISO9660 file system, ... In order to exploit this vulnerability, an attacker must be able to mount ...
    (Securiteam)
  • Re: Interplatform (interprocess, interlanguage) communication
    ... If I'm using XML at all, and JAXB suits, I'll use JAXB. ... typically I don't deal a whole lot with anything "security ... a 3rd party could somehow break the app and get control of the users' OS ... standards like the Java Secure Coding Guidelines, ...
    (comp.lang.java.programmer)
  • Re: Security Exception when deploying a VB.NET 2003 Solution
    ... It runs fine on any workstation. ... folder 2 levels up from the BIN folder where the application resides. ... Microsoft .NET security errors upon trying to start the Executable. ... I bet the workstaion is WinXP and your app is trying to write data( ...
    (microsoft.public.vsnet.general)
  • Re: FSI Indices with translates the answer
    ... directory of the file system that one is within, ... there are other MV dbms products that have virtually no security ... MV vendors should provide that functionality required by "ALL" users. ... when you fire anyone who points out problems ...
    (comp.databases.pick)