Re: [PATCH 1/7] Adding empia base driver



(Note: I'm reposting this since it bounced on several mailinglists due
to "Too many recipients". I'm now only sending it to the mailinglists
as I assume that most of the recipients are on at least one of these
mailinglists. Apologies if this is not the case.)


Hi Markus,

As promised I've done a review of your empia driver and looked at what
needs to be done to get it into the kernel.

First of all, I've no doubt that your empia driver is better and
supports more devices than the current em28xx driver. I also have no
problem adding your driver separate from the current driver. It's been
done before (certain networking drivers spring to mind) and while
obviously not ideal I expect that the older em28xx driver can probably
be removed after a year or something like that.

In my opinion it's pretty much hopeless trying to convert the current
em28xx driver into what you have. It's a huge amount of work that no
one wants to do and (in this case) with very little benefit. Of course,
Mauro has the final say in this.

While there is some cleaning up to do in your code (coding style, some
copyright/license clarifications), that is not a big deal. The coding
style cleanups are a fair amount of work, but I think we can probably
spread that out over several people and get that done quickly.

What I definitely would recommend is to use video_ioctl2 rather than
video_usercopy. The latter function will disappear in the future. I
think the policy for new drivers is to use video_ioctl2, so this is
probably a required task before it can be merged. Doing this will
improve maintenance of the code as well, so it's useful to do this
anyway. I think it's better if you do it, but I guess some volunteer
can probably be found if needed. It's not a difficult task.

Now the real problems are with three duplicate i2c drivers: cx25843,
xc3028 and xc5000.

To start with the easiest one: cx25843. There already is a driver for
this (cx25840) and the empia driver should use that one. Since I
maintain cx25840 the easiest approach for you is to see if you can get
me hardware (em28xx + cx25843) so that I can test and update cx25843 to
provide proper empia support. The alternative is that we work together
on this, but that's probably more work for both of us. I most
definitely do *not* want to duplicate this driver. Windows drivers
duplicate this stuff all the time, but we're not Windows and having one
driver ensures that fixes or new functionality become available to all
bridge drivers that use it.

The same reasoning is true for xc3028 and xc5000. In addition, the
licensing of these sources is very vague. Is it even allowed to
distribute them under a GPL license? There is no GPL license in the
sources, yet in the module you specify GPL. This needs to be clarified
first.

I see two ways forward when it comes to these drivers:

1) The empia driver switches to the current xceive drivers that are
already in the kernel. No doubt this means that xceive driver bugs will
surface with certain devices, but those are bugs that the xceive driver
maintainer will have to fix. Obviously assistance would be appreciated,
but the bottom line is that a) your driver is finally in the kernel,
and b) there is a lot more pressure to fix bugs in the xceive drivers
than is the case otherwise. Yes, some devices will not work initially
with the empia driver, but I expect that to be a temporary situation.

2) Your xceive drivers replace the current drivers. This will require
that a) the license situation is clarified, b) the drivers are modified
to fit the current v4l-dvb tuner architecture. This option will mean a
lot of work for you since you are the maintainer of these drivers. In
addition, I forsee a lot of flaming if we go this way.

BTW, I noticed that the current xc5000 driver is very similar to yours
but with proper copyrights/license notices and coding style. So for
this driver option 1 is definitely the way to go.

To be honest, I don't see option 2 as viable. I forsee too many
inter-personal problems that will appear if we go that way. Option 1
has the big advantage that all you need to do is to file a bug report
if it doesn't work with a certain device. And in the meantime users can
fallback to your stand-alone driver until it's fixed in the kernel.
Obviously, if you can state in the bug report what the precise problem
is, so much the better.

So my recommendation would be to:

1) Switch to using the current xceive drivers in your empia driver. This
is something you have to do, I'm afraid. Unless someone would
volunteer? I personally do not have enough experience with this to do
it.

2) Switch to using the cx25840 driver. If I can get hardware, then I can
do this, otherwise we have to do this together. Initially we probably
have to disable devices using the cx25840 until the cx25840 driver has
been fixed for the empia driver.

3) Switch to video_ioctl2 in the empia driver. You can do that, but we
can probably find a volunteer as well.

4) Conform the code to the coding style. If several people can help with
this we can get it done pretty quickly.

5) Merge the empia driver alongside the current em28xx driver.

There are no doubt some things I missed, but I don't think I missed
anything major. I've put up a hg tree here:

http://linuxtv.org/hg/~hverkuil/v4l-dvb-em28xx/

This allows you to compile the empia module alongside the em28xx module.
Note that I've removed the empia cx25843 module in the last changeset
in order to test which dependencies the driver had on that module. So
if you want to test this tree with an empia+cx25843 device, then don't
get the latest changeset, but the one before that.

My tree does contain the empia xceive drivers, though. Perhaps someone
more knowledgeable with DVB can take a look to see how much work it is
to convert to the kernel xceive drivers? And to see if I overlooked any
DVB-related major obstacles?

I think this is a reasonable roadmap to finally get this in. If everyone
can pitch in then it really shouldn't take that much work to get it
into v4l-dvb and from there to 2.6.29.

Regards,

Hans Verkuil
--
To unsubscribe from this list: send the line "unsubscribe linux-kernel" in
the body of a message to majordomo@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
More majordomo info at http://vger.kernel.org/majordomo-info.html
Please read the FAQ at http://www.tux.org/lkml/



Relevant Pages

  • Re: [PATCH 1/7] Adding empia base driver
    ... As promised I've done a review of your empia driver and looked at what ... needs to be done to get it into the kernel. ... The empia driver switches to the current xceive drivers that are ...
    (Linux-Kernel)
  • Re: [PATCH 1/7] Adding empia base driver
    ... As promised I've done a review of your empia driver and looked at what ... supports more devices than the current em28xx driver. ... opening an ALSA device switch the card from digital to radio mode, ...
    (Linux-Kernel)
  • Re: [PATCH 1/7] Adding empia base driver
    ... As promised I've done a review of your empia driver and looked at what ... supports more devices than the current em28xx driver. ... on some already fixed bugs and remove some improvements that the upstream driver ...
    (Linux-Kernel)
  • Re: [linux-dvb] [PATCH 1/7] Adding empia base driver
    ... As promised I've done a review of your empia driver and looked at what ... supports more devices than the current em28xx driver. ...
    (Linux-Kernel)
  • Re: XP SP3 Details?
    ... Why the warning when adding/updating a new driver that the driver ... I do hope windows isn't ever used on planes or control ... ms claims if bugs & unreliability are acceptable. ... the hips body and soul to the God of Microsoft because they ...
    (microsoft.public.windowsxp.general)