RHEL 3 migration problems

From: Josh Kelley (josh_at_jbc.edu)
Date: 01/29/04

  • Next message: Cameron Simpson: "Re: User wit dot in red hat 9"
    To: Red Hat List <redhat-list@redhat.com>
    Date: Thu, 29 Jan 2004 16:19:44 -0500
    
    

    I'm working on migrating our servers from Red Hat 7.2 and 9 to RHEL 3
    and keep running into problems. There are a number of packages and
    features (vim-X11, sendmail-devel, sendmail-doc, mailman, mtx, arpwatch,
    ReiserFS suport, ...) that I've come to depend on for our servers that
    have been removed from RHEL 3. I can build RPMs myself or install
    software from source if I have to, but I'd prefer not to have to do so,
    especially now that I'm using a non-gratis enterprise OS. I've also run
    into more problems with bugs or glitches in RHEL 3 than I'm used to from
    previous releases of RHL. For example, RHEL 3's Amanda RPMs are
    apparently compiled without Samba support, even though they claim to
    offer it, and Samba support doesn't work even if it is compiled in.
    (I've reported this on Bugzilla but haven't heard anything back yet.)
    As another example, the iptables-restore program is unable to restore
    the default high security firewall from the Red Hat install, which
    leaves your system without a firewall on boot. This problem was
    reported to Red Hat, was fixed in unofficial RPMs, and then was
    inexplicably marked as closed without ever releasing the RPMs on RHN
    (see http://bugzilla.redhat.com/bugzilla/show_bug.cgi?id=111999).

    We purchased the academic edition of RHEL 3, so I don't think that paid
    support from Red Hat is an option on any of these issues.

    So, with the above in mind, I guess I have a few questions. Does anyone
    know if or where I could find the following information:
    a list of packages removed from RHEL 3
    rationales for packages' removal from RHEL 3 and suggestions for
    alternatives
    information on migrating from RHL to RHEL, including info on the above
    topics (Red Hat's migration whitepaper is too vague to be useful here.)

    Are there any sites that provide third-party RPMs for RHEL 3?

    When reporting bugs to Red Hat's Bugzilla, any idea what the average
    time for a response is? Any idea when I could expect to see official
    Red Hat RPMs to fix that iptables bug?

    Apologies if this isn't the right forum for this sort of topic or if
    it's already been discussed. Thank you for your time.

    Josh Kelley

    -- 
    redhat-list mailing list
    unsubscribe mailto:redhat-list-request@redhat.com?subject=unsubscribe
    https://www.redhat.com/mailman/listinfo/redhat-list
    

  • Next message: Cameron Simpson: "Re: User wit dot in red hat 9"

    Relevant Pages

    • Re: Online resizing support for ext3 in RHEL 4
      ... RHEL questions should be posted to the distribution-specific lists, ... You'll get far better reponses that way since the Red Hat ... To which Shadowman replies: ...
      (RedHat)
    • Re: Red Hat Enterprise Linux 4?
      ... I have RHEL ver 3 and 4 i bought 3 and got the upgrade to four for free ... might think of it as a service pack maybe. ... Red Hat Enterprise Linux AS ...
      (linux.redhat)
    • Re: Red Hat Enterprise Linux 4?
      ... I have RHEL ver 3 and 4 i bought 3 and got the upgrade to four for free ... might think of it as a service pack maybe. ... Red Hat Enterprise Linux AS ...
      (linux.redhat)
    • RE: Free RH ES 4.0 or equvelent
      ... At least one was related to one of the dhcp packages. ... > hard for their package to install on a rebuild. ... > don't need any Red Hat support, can afford to wait an extra ... > subscribed RHEL distributions. ...
      (RedHat)
    • Re: RHEL without License?
      ... > was asked by someone if they can continue running RHEL after their ... > yearly subscription has expired. ... Red Hat Enterprise Linux is not licensed from Red Hat - it's a ... subscription model and the license is the GPL. ...
      (RedHat)