Re: [opensuse] Reiserfs unstable under load using large LV



On Thursday 07 June 2007 13:29, James Knott wrote:
Carlos E. R. wrote:
The Thursday 2007-06-07 at 10:12 +0200, Morten Bjørnsvik wrote:
Maybe that was a fact years ago with immature releases pre 2.4.19

versions.

That is _NOT_ true now. XFS is probably the most stressed filesystem
on the planet. Most Hollywood studio backbones and linux

workstations runs xfs.

It's only drawback is delete which is slow by design, because it has to
traverse the inodes to figure out which blocks to delete and not a

direct hashed

pointer-table.

Slow? It is the faster deleting large files, almost instantaneous. So
much
so that it is recomended for use with mythtv for that very reason.

I've used the xfs_repair, xfsdump, xfsrestore and xfs_db tools

extensively.

I've had lots of bad blocks, zeroed inodes and other disk failures.

I've almost

everytime managed to restore most of the data on the disk.

I have an unrepairable xfs partition that crashes xfs_repair every time,
with a bug report.

FWIW, I recently tried installing Ubuntu and thought I'd try XFS for a
change. I got a warning message that GRUB has problems with XFS, so I
went with JFS on the boot partition instead and XFS on /home.

--
Use OpenOffice.org <http://www.openoffice.org>

Never had any problems with XFS.
As people have stated; it cashes alot, so if you are unlucky and get at power
out at the wrong moment, the filesystem MAY corrupt.
But so far i have been lucky i guess. Even with power outs i havent had any
trashed drives (yet)

XFS is fast, reliable and scales well, or so i have read.
And besides; SGI wouldnt use it if it werent stable...


--
         /Rikard

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
email   : rikard.j@xxxxxxxxxx
web     : http://www.rikjoh.com
mob: : +46 (0)763 19 76 25
------------------------ Public PGP fingerprint ----------------------------
< 15 28 DF 78 67 98 B2 16 1F D3 FD C5 59 D4 B6 78  46 1C EE 56 >

Attachment: pgpHhqrVSx1Jd.pgp
Description: PGP signature



Relevant Pages

  • Re: Linux filesystems was [Re: Debian cd supporting ext4.]
    ... I'm guessing most of them didn't look before taking the XFS leap. ... What were your results when you did this same power yank test with ext2/3, ... I've been using btrfs for my "/" file system for a few months now on my ... Toward the beginning I did suffer some dpkg database corruption due ...
    (Debian-User)
  • Re: Open source storage
    ... you lose power while XFS is building its extant, ... power loss: the defined semantics of any normal Unix-style file system ... flushed to disk may or may not be on the disk, in whole or in part, ... I see your point, but it strikes me as one of the 'a little bit pregnant' variety: absent explicit write-through or cache-flush control, *any* Unix file system will tend to produce data inconsistencies after interruption, the only question being just how many. ...
    (comp.arch.storage)
  • Re: Open source storage
    ... you lose power while XFS is building its extant, ... power loss: the defined semantics of any normal Unix-style file system ... flushed to disk may or may not be on the disk, in whole or in part, ...
    (comp.arch.storage)
  • Re: Open source storage
    ... you lose power while XFS is building its extant, ... There's nothing there that even remotely hints at data corruption on ... power loss: the defined semantics of any normal Unix-style file system ...
    (comp.arch.storage)
  • Re: Open source storage
    ... you lose power while XFS is building its extant, ... There's nothing there that even remotely hints at data corruption on ... power loss: the defined semantics of any normal Unix-style file system ...
    (comp.arch.storage)