Re: GPL compliance

Daniel Carrera wrote:
On Fri, 2006-30-06 at 16:35 +0200, Alexander Skwar wrote:
I disagree. If a user got Ubuntu (or any GPL software) on CD and
has no Internet, why should he be forced to buy something (Internet
access) just so that he can make use of his rights? That doesn't make
sense to me.

Indeed... the requirement on 3(a) of "medium customarily used for
software interchange" is a bit vague and fuzzy. My interpretation would
be that if you use the same medium you used for the binaries then that's
fair enough. So, if I'm distributing binaries on-line, then putting the
sources on-line on the same location would be ok. But if I'm giving you
the binaries on a CD, then the sources should be available on CD and I
expect that putting them on-line would *not* satisfy the 3(a)
requirement. But this interpretation is mostly a guess. The license text
on 3(a) really isn't very clear.


I don't see it as all that fuzzy, and if anything, it's looser, not more
restrictive. Besides, this would be under section 3(b), assuming you
got Ubuntu on CD.

The requirement, in simple terms is any one of the following:

a) Provide the source code right along with the binaries.
b) Provide the source code somewhere else.
c) Point to a 3rd party that will provide the source code.


Don't try to parse a legal document as if it was a C program. When it
gets to court, standards of reasonableness apply. Is online
distribution a "medium customarily used for software interchange"?
Well, how many millions of programs are distributed that way, including
virtually every linux distribution ever made? Someone trying to suggest
that the internet is not often used to download programs would be
laughed at.

Remember, the requirements are from the distributors perspective, not
the end user.

--
ubuntu-users mailing list
ubuntu-users@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
https://lists.ubuntu.com/mailman/listinfo/ubuntu-users

Relevant Pages

  • Re: nios2 toolchain sources
    ... IANAL but I've dealt with the GPL for a *long* time. ... Always include the source with the binaries. ... source code, which must be distributed under the terms of Sections ... cost of physically performing source distribution, ...
    (comp.arch.fpga)
  • Re: GPL compliance
    ... has no Internet, why should he be forced to buy something (Internet ... So, if I'm distributing binaries on-line, then putting the ... Provide the source code right along with the binaries. ... distribution a "medium customarily used for software interchange"? ...
    (Ubuntu)
  • Re: CompareSoft ripping off GPL products?
    ... performing source distribution, a complete machine-readable copy of the ... corresponding source code, to be distributed under the terms of Sections 1 ... recipients of the binaries. ...
    (uk.comp.os.linux)
  • Re: Funimation v Shinsen-Subs smackdown
    ... already existing content distribution categories. ... internet distribution, it MUST fall under existing laws. ... agreements with regards to "home video" and broadcast. ... I am not necessarily convinced that they outweigh the fact that if you asked pretty much any person on the street what a "home video" was they would give an answer involving a VHS tape or a DVD or the like. ...
    (rec.arts.anime.misc)
  • Re: P-value from chi-square value: source code
    ... the accuracy being lost by using good algorithms. ... I do not think an algorithm for a chi-squared distribution ... TOMS708 and its code for the cdf of the gamma ... Anyone looking for source code for the gamma distribution should watch ...
    (sci.stat.math)