Re: Booting - Enterprise Volume Management System

Alexander Skwar wrote:

Toby Kelsey <toby_kelsey@xxxxxxxxxxxx>:


Interesting. Looking at the HOWTO, it seems that LVM combines the main
disadvantage of separate partitions - having to manually unmount and resize when
you run out of space


unmount? Have you actually read the howto?

Perhaps you should try reading it.

" ext2/ext3

Unless you have patched your kernel with the ext2online patch it is necessary to
unmount the file system before resizing it."

Reiserfs, xfs and jfs can be grown mounted, but reiserfs is slower and allegedly
buggier than other filesystems, and xfs and jfs are unsuitable for LVM as I have
mentioned already.

- with the main disadvantage of one big partition -
allowing fs corruption and installers to affect user and system data together.


What are you talking about?

You don't think there are any disadvantages of one big partition? Why even
bother with LVM on a single disk if you can just make one big partition?

The main advantage appears being able to resize logical volumes and filesystems
easily, but for jfs "this is extremely error prone"


How so? mount -o remount,resize /your/jfs

Perhas you know better than the HOWTO:

"Known Kernel Bug

Some kernel versions have problems with this syntax (2.6.0 is known to have this
problem). In this case you have to explicitly specify the new size of the
filesystem in blocks. This is extremely error prone as you must know the
blocksize of your filesystem and calculate the new size based on those units. "

Until "some kernels" are identified or fixed it is not safe. I am not going to
continue pasting blocks of text from the HOWTO every time you profess ignorance.
Please read it.

and even for ext2/3 "there
is currently no e2fsadm equivalent for LVM 2


True, but ext3 can be made larger online, AFAIK. I don't use ext3, though.

With a kernel patch which is judged "rather dangereous" as I already said.
If you only use reiserfs anyway then LVM is more useful.

Since you cannot shrink xfs and jfs the main functionality becomes
useless for many advanced users.


Wrong. Mostly, filesystems will grow. It's, in my experience, quite
rare, that filesystems need to be made smaller.

You can grow and move partitions with parted anyway, so LVM has no advantage if
that's what you restrict it to. Of course you can also use LVM with multiple
disks, and it has a genuine advantage there. I suspect it is not as fast as
using specific software or hardware RAID though, and the HOWTO says striping
with LVM can actually reduce performance if you have more than one LV per disk.

While it may be useful for servers, with confidence-building statements like "it
seems that the online resizing patch is rather dangerous" I would suggest it is
not yet suitable for a home or laptop system.


Wrong. On what experience do you base your conclusion? On your false reading?

Based on the HOWTO. Please read it.

LVM has its place if you know what you are doing (and have multiple disks with
partitions which grow and never shrink), but the "LVM is good for everybody,
even laptop users" rhetoric I responded to was OTT.

Toby

--
ubuntu-users mailing list
ubuntu-users@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
https://lists.ubuntu.com/mailman/listinfo/ubuntu-users

Relevant Pages

  • Re: Booting - Enterprise Volume Management System
    ... Since the main LVM advantage is meant to be easy resizing, ... you could just as well use that space to copy or resize basic partitions. ... So you know better than the HOWTO that no recent kernels are affected. ... I don't claim you never have to unmount, but with LVM you have to unmount with ...
    (Ubuntu)
  • Re: Booting - Enterprise Volume Management System
    ... Looking at the HOWTO, it seems that LVM combines the main ... disadvantage of separate partitions - having to manually unmount and resize when ... Sadly, there are no filesystems out there, which support ...
    (Ubuntu)
  • Re: partition limits on scsi drives?
    ... With LVM you can leave those general limits of the ... They are not very flexible, especially you normally can't extend partitions ... Extension of filesystems can happen online. ...
    (Fedora)
  • Re: Booting - Enterprise Volume Management System
    ... system to adjust it, then you have to umount it to adjust it. ... nothing to do with LVM and everything to do with file systems. ... partitions, then this is negated isn't it? ... And to make the most use of it, you need filesystems that are fully ...
    (Ubuntu)
  • Re: Booting - Enterprise Volume Management System
    ... Since the main LVM advantage is meant to be easy resizing, ... negate that - except for growth into unused disk-space. ... you could just as well use that space to copy or resize basic partitions. ... and in that case you need to be able to shrink as well as grow filesystems. ...
    (Ubuntu)