Linux mail fine, Windows not so.

From: LLFormat (dev-null_at_localhost.localdomain)
Date: 07/30/03


Date: Wed, 30 Jul 2003 15:37:59 +0100

Hi,

After setting up my mail server ok on a seperate RH9 box, I decided to
test Outlook and Outlook Express on my main machine's XP partition.

Connecting to ipop3 was no problem, but when I tried to send a mail
through the mail servers' SMTP port, I continually got 'Relaying Denied'.

(I must add that I have two boxes on my 'network', the mail server is
total RH9, and my main machine is dual boot between RH9 and XP. A
Linksys router connects them up to a cable modem.)

I managed to get mail sent from Outlook and OE by updating the access.db
on my mail server with the address of the router, telling it to relay
for this device. I did this after checking my mail logs on the server,
and finding many references to my router.

I have a feeling that this is a bit of a security risk, and I was
wondering if anyone could confirm or deny this for me.

By telling Sendmail to RELAY all mail from my router (192.168.1.1),
would I be effectively setting myself up with an open relay ?

I don't have to do this in Linux. I simply have the default entries,
with one domain I dislike blocked. It works perfectly.

I tried renaming the computer in Windows XP to the same hostname I use
for Linux, but it didn't work. I couldn't do the linux 'hostname.domain
hostname' entry in Windows, and when I tried to define my domain name in
'domain name' in the Windows network config window, I was informed that
'no domain controller was found'. I presume this refers to a Windows
server with Active Directory or something, that needs to be running on
my network for it to use the domain name I use in Linux.

To recap, Linux doesn't need a router-relay entry in access.db, but
Windows does. Anyone have more of a clue than me ? (easily achieved)

Thanks for your time.

-- 
Regards,
LLFormat.
'Partitions exist but they do not exist' - fdisk.


Relevant Pages

  • RE: a spy problem
    ... U can use it with a linux box, ... > the company (linked by a switch to the router and then ... > to the ISP) and each employee daily uses more then one ... If you can afford and have the knowledge to set up your own mail server then ...
    (Security-Basics)
  • Re: Thunderbird mail client, outgoing mail not working eventhough disabled firewall
    ... > Outlook on Windows no problem at all?. ... > Linux mesage, ... going out when I send a message from Thunderbird. ... (First shutdown your own local mail server if you're running one.) ...
    (comp.os.linux.misc)
  • Re: Thunderbird mail client, outgoing mail not working eventhough disabled firewall
    ... > Outlook on Windows no problem at all?. ... > Linux mesage, ... going out when I send a message from Thunderbird. ... (First shutdown your own local mail server if you're running one.) ...
    (alt.os.linux.redhat)
  • Re: Encounter Table for rec.games.frp.dnd ?
    ... I suspect that I fried my web & mail server by ... I once bumped my old firewall when the case was open. ... > When I finally get a new PC, it'll be that Linux box. ... I don't entirely trust Windows software ...
    (rec.games.frp.dnd)
  • Re: [RFC] Virtualization steps
    ... to run Linux, Windows, Solaris and BEOS unmodified in 4-5 VMs would be far more useful. ... For example, I know the universities which run VPS for every faculty web site, for every department, mail server and so on. ... What needs I have for Linux environments are answered by jails and/or UML. ...
    (Linux-Kernel)