Re: Audio CDs Render Suse 9.1 Useless

From: Enric Martínez (runle_at_saraswati.tk)
Date: 07/03/04


Date: Sat, 03 Jul 2004 17:02:24 +0200


-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----
Hash: SHA1

nikoli wrote:

> Hello all. Whenever I try to play a plain old audio CD (Friday Night
> In San Francisco in this case) the entire system is
> halted/unresponsive for 30 seconds or so and the CD never plays. ksCD
> will open and show the cddb info, and actually appears to be playing
> the CD, but there is no sound. And I have checked that all volume
> levels are turned on.

Check first if the direct audio cable is propperly switched to the CD
drive and to the motherboard.

If you get a system freeze you should check if the disk is OK, damaged
CD's can produce what we call 'trashing' and stay in 'uninterruptable
sleep' mode, which makes that you will be unable to kill the process,
as it is in kernel mode.

Another cause for this are dirty or damaged lenses.
 
> I cannot access the CD drive in Konquerer when there is an audio CD in
> the drive.
> I cannot access the CD from XMMS or mplayer when there's an audio CD
> in the drive.
> I cannot access the CD drive /media/cdrecorder from Konsole when
> there's an audio CD in the drive.

You cannot access the CD drive with an audio cd is inside anyway either,
audio CD's des not belong to a file system which normal OSes can
handle, you can surely get a track list, but this is not accessing the
drive.

> nikoli@linux:/media/cdrecorder> ls
> /bin/ls: .: No medium found

Damaged disc.
 
> This is only with audio CDs. The drive works flawlessly with mp3 CDs
> or just plain old data CDs. It will also burn CDs with k3b no problem.

This only confirms that your OS is OK and that the drive has (prolly)
no hardware failures.
 
> The most frustrating part is that the LED on my drive (hp cd-writer
> 9500 series) will light up and I can hear the drive spinning. While
> this is happening, no other programs are accessable. I have to wait
> for the whole process to stop before I can use another app.

This is what I told you: "uninterruptable sleep", this is a feature
related to the linux kernel and the hardware itself, it can also
happen on windows, if you have a windows version available try to play
the same CD. Antoher cause of failure could be a damn DRM-protection.
 
> I've not tried playing a CD from any other window manager than KDE.
> Maybe this is a KDE bug or something?

Nope, it's hardware related and involves the kernel, the disc, the
drive and probably the DMA chips.

If it is a DRM issue, try installing the DRM modules shipped with SuSE,
if this solves the problem it's 100% sure that a cop protection is
isntalled, complain to the manufacturer, as a consumer you have the
right to be able to play the CD wherever you want and these protections
can avoid playing the CD on your car's drive or on some normal
non-computer based hardware.

- --
R3G4RDZ
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
Version: GnuPG v1.2.4 (GNU/Linux)

iD8DBQFA5sqHzxMJf1zyJjcRAj0bAKDjN2iaqBbAc5mkb8m/fnuNMarjWwCcC/bS
WJi+MZ8MlyLyHT5/tu4cPOo=
=NNxv
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----



Relevant Pages

  • Re: problem getting audio to work properly on my FC4 box
    ... I've confirmed that it's not a hardware issue. ... I believe I've never bothered to see if I can play audio CD's from it. ... I added a 2nd optical drive (according to CD Player - CD-RW CRX216E) that once was fully functional in another PC. ...
    (Fedora)
  • Re: Problem in playing downloading music in CD player
    ... that gives the burn type, audio, data, or highmat audio. ... > in Computer but not with my CD player. ... >>as purchased CDs and will play on most newer players. ...
    (microsoft.public.windowsxp.music)
  • [SLE] Re: Help with Audio CD recognition under SuSE 9.1 Pro
    ... > I know that the sound card is set up correct because all other sounds play. ... Audio CDs play by a different route to all other sounds on your PC. ...
    (SuSE)
  • Re: Sound hardware access for RO
    ... RO if there is no way to get that though the hardware to a DAC than ... can play such files. ... to run software that performs more sophisticated use of the sound card, ... such as running audio creation or editing software. ...
    (comp.sys.acorn.programmer)
  • Re: Help needed: sound/audio only semi-working
    ... audio all I get is absolute silence. ... cdcontrol -f /dev/acd0 play 1 ... even though the video seems to be playing perfectly. ... I had already ripped all of my CDs to .ogg files, ...
    (freebsd-questions)