Re: polling



david.tucker@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx wrote:

You have UDP all wrong, it is really only useful for talking to a lot
of clients at once. For example if you want to push the same file out
to 20 machines, in theory UDP is 20 times faster than with "normal"
TCP/IP communications. (Theory only because UDP drops packets like a
dog).

This is very misleading. UDP doesn't inherently drop packets, that depends on the underlying transport. On a good network with sufficiently powerful machines there will be zero packet loss. On a lossy network, even TCP/IP performance will suffer due to the retransmits. You can't get something for nothing.

The correct way to put it is that UDP provides no delivery guarantees.

If that does not work, by a better router/switch. Some of the cheaper
ones have a hard time with UDP in general.

Weird suggestion, there. A switch certainly does not care about anything above the ethernet layer so why would it care about UDP ? Even routers are mostly concerned with the IP layer only.
.



Relevant Pages

  • Re: Netgear RP614 leaking
    ... local machine send a UDP message to the remote host seconds earlier. ... Say remotehost has been configured to send a UDP password request to ... machines from reaching inside machines as an accidental side-effect. ...
    (comp.os.linux.networking)
  • W2K UDP Based DDoS Trojan
    ... We're seeing a small number of Windows 2000/IIS5 machines launching a UDP ... is a shadow brushed away | Network Security & Enterprise ...
    (Incidents)
  • RE: rpc-srv/tcp: nfsd: sent only -107 bytes (fwd)
    ... best with large groups of machines being heavily ... The situation I had was more machines, and more mounts ... >> The solution that I came to was to use UDP mounts, ... >> to use UDP mounts everywere if you have enough tcp mounts ...
    (Linux-Kernel)
  • Begun seeing XP PCs unable to upgrade WinCE
    ... images using the UDP BOOTME method. ... Some machines will see the BOOTME, ... The upgrading mechanism involves UDP messages, ...
    (microsoft.public.windowsce.embedded)
  • Re: UDP question
    ... When I run both the client and server on the same machine, ... different machines, only a few UDP messages are dropped. ...
    (comp.os.linux.development.system)