Re: DVDs - no "industry standard"

From: Steve Wolfe (unt_at_codon.com)
Date: 02/09/04


Date: Mon, 9 Feb 2004 01:47:22 -0700


> Last year, I got an old 8mm movie burned to DVD professionally. They
wanted
> to know my make and model of DVD player. When I asked why, they said that
> there is no agree "industry standard" for DVDs, and that way they can make
> it work on my player and 90% of the others.

  They're most likely referring to the type of disc, not the encoding.
There is an industry standard, it's a stamped metal disc, sandwiched between
two plastic discs. You know, the kind you get when you go buy a movie at
the store. However, because it costs a lot of money to have those made for
a one-time deal (probably in the 5-figure range), the shop you went to used
a DVD{-R/+R/-RW/+RW}. Once you get into those, things get complicated, and
for any one of them, there's bound to be a player somewhere that won't
support it. Depending on the format you choose, the percentage of players
that won't cooperate could be anywhere from 3% to 30%.

> We have an old TV with no
> direct DVD connections. Their disc ran perfectly where a store-bought
copy
> of "Lord of the Rings" was struggling with the inferior setup.

   While you don't describe the "struggling", at a casual guess, it's
probably either the encoding or the Macrovision copy-protection, not the
media itself that causes your machine to struggle.

steve



Relevant Pages

  • Re: Confused over Womble output options
    ... I'm still unable to get the encoding result I expect. ... I note that the playback of the AVI file in Womble's Input ... Terry this is my conversion using Womble - first selected the PAL DVD ... various ways depending on the player. ...
    (rec.video.desktop)
  • DVD ...
    ... dvd our latin thing ... dvd p1400 player sd toshiba ... dvd pc won't play black screen ... dvd photo al free ...
    (rec.autos.tech)
  • Re: Blu-Ray or HD, whos gonna win the format war
    ... now it's looking more and more like Blu-Ray film media sales are ... Joe public only really got to grips with DVD and widescreen CRT TV's a few ... shell out another thousand for a Blu-ray player... ... counting a PC) in different rooms and it is usually expected that a disc can ...
    (uk.media.dvd)
  • Re: Confused over Womble output options
    ... I'm still unable to get the encoding result I expect. ... I note that the playback of the AVI file in Womble's Input ... Terry this is my conversion using Womble - first selected the PAL DVD ... various ways depending on the player. ...
    (rec.video.desktop)
  • Re: Help with burning DVD-Audio
    ... look like typical video DVD files - a VIDEO_TS folder with VOB files. ... majority of DVD players on the market today don't support DVD-Audio. ... frequently used to create a disc that can be played back on any DVD ... If you don't have a player capable of playing back DVD-Audio discs you ...
    (rec.music.gdead)