Re: RAID-5 of 4x IBM IC35L073UCDY10 incompatible with SEAGATE ST373207LC

From: Victor Matare (victorbenedikt.matare_at_rwth-aachen.de)
Date: 05/03/05

  • Next message: Joe Beanfish: "Re: Linux support for voice modems?" 
    Date: Tue, 03 May 2005 21:18:51 +0200

    John-Paul Stewart wrote:
    > Victor Mataré wrote:
    >
    >> Hi,
    >>
    >> I'm running a RAID-5 of 4x IBM IC35L073UCDY10 on an ICP Vortex GDT8514RZ
    >> SCSI/RAID-Controller, firmware 2.44.02-RC7B (current). It is to be
    >> expanded by 2 SEAGATE ST373207LC, but the expand command in the
    >> controller's console fails with the message "no suitable disks found".
    >> This seems to be due to a compatibility issue of the IBM drives. The IBM
    >> support doesn't seem to be of much help - the firmware update (S29A)
    >> they sent me made no difference.
    >> If anyone has experience with expanding RAID arrays of IBM disks or
    >> similar situations, please tell me...
    >
    >
    > Some RAID controllers simply refuse to work unless all drives are
    > identical brand and model. I don't think it's a compatability issue
    > with the IBM drives so much as it's an issue with the controller. Check
    > with the controller manufacturer for information; there's a chance they
    > might have a workaround (if this is indeed your problem).

    The controller definitely does support using different drives in a
    single array. It even leaves a "tolerance gap" of about 10 MB of unused
    space at the end of the disks to ensure that drives with a slightly
    smaller capacity can still be added to the array. I'm pretty sure it's
    an incompatibility issue with either the IBM- or the Seagate-disks.
    If this can't be resolved, I'd appreciate some tips on how to find out
    who (IBM, Seagate or maybe ICP Vortex) has been messing with the
    standards there, in order to find someone to "blame" for this ;)

    thx4help, 

    -- 
Victor Mataré
* Server- & Network-Administration *
Lehrstuhl für Ingenieurgeologie und Hydrogeologie der RWTH-Aachen
Lochnerstr. 4-20
52064 Aachen
Germany
http://www.lih.rwth-aachen.de
Ph: +49-0241-80-97130
Fx: +49-0241-80-92280
  • Next message: Joe Beanfish: "Re: Linux support for voice modems?"