Re: Can a (second) hard disc consist of only 1 extended/logical partition? Or is at least one primary necessary?



On Tue, 22 Apr 2008 05:04:07 +0200, s. keeling wrote:


The style I like is to have one partition for /boot

Why? What's that get you if /sbin is unreadable?

This isn't to make /sbin's content available; that's what RAID is for.
This is to make the content of /boot available to GRUB. As far as I know
- and please let me know if I'm out of date on this - GRUB doesn't
"speak" LVM.


[...]
Or, have a 40 Gb disk, install (a la Aragorn) $OS, add a ca. 3 Gb
/scratch, and I've 26 Gb left to portion out whenever I wish. What does
lvm gain you in this situation but an added level of complexity?

A layer of indirection so that, when you "portion out whenever you wish",
you don't need to worry that you've the necessary contiguous blocks.


[Sorry for the rant ...]

Yeah, what's that about? Did LVM kick you as a child or something
<laugh>?

- Andrew
.



Relevant Pages

  • Re: Debian + LVM + RAID1
    ... Grub can apparently be on LVM these days; ... Installing GRUB while /boot is on RAID and/or LVM should be ...
    (Debian-User)
  • Re: rescue bootable cd ???
    ... filesystem in lvm on software raid 5. ... autodetection just isn't running on startup; ... The problem is grub. ...
    (Debian-User)
  • Re: Linux LVM-RAID wie in AIX?
    ... Werd mir EVMS mal anschauen. ... Warum setzt du das Raid nicht auf LVM-Volumes statt auf physikalische ... Aendere die Reihenfolge (*erst* LVM, ...
    (de.comp.os.unix.linux.misc)
  • Re: Help: resizing partitions on a production server!
    ... >> the second disk as a PV and migrate the volumes across without any ... >> you're using RAID for your data, why aren't you using it for your swap ... If you're using LVM on ... means put in on a separate RAID array). ...
    (uk.comp.os.linux)
  • Re: Linux LVM software raid, and SAN question.
    ... you need massive redundancy supplied by two SAN devices, ... Software raid, ... LVM to mirror and handle the whole damned thing? ... different switch and a storage port on the same array as the other ...
    (comp.arch.storage)