Re: The ole "Linux vs Windows Server 2003" question - help?

From: Joe (joe_at_jretrading.com)
Date: 04/12/04


Date: Mon, 12 Apr 2004 20:02:30 +0100

In message <1595339b99dd0358b70a80f544418aca@news.teranews.com>, Bob
Mariotti <r.mariotti@financialdatacorp.com> writes
>Gents;
>
>I have a client with about 50 desktops all running Windows XP. We
>also have AIX and Linux servers running Samba providing file storage
>service and the LInux box runs Lotus Notes.
>
>Another firm has made a proposal to install a Windows Server 2003
>machine which is supposed to solve all my clients woes by providing a
>more secured file storage environment and centralized print
>management.
>
>I say "Bogus"!
>
>As I create my detailed response to this unfortunate scenario I was
>hoping that if any of my fellow Linux gurus cold provide some detail,
>insight or advise my way it would help with my response.
>
>I know that some say "let them install the Windows server and then
>charge them when they come back". But the actual truth is that there
>is not room for multiple vendors supporting different platforms.
>
>Thanks for any assistance/advise provided.
>
So what kind of woes does your client have at the moment? Why is he
proposing to spend GBP3000+ on software, and presumably pay a similar
amount again to this other business to install it?

And why would anyone in their right mind want a single point of failure
for the printing needs of 50 users? Someone prints something gigantic,
runs the temp file partition out of space and nobody prints anything for
the next half hour. Or more, if nobody local knows how to fix it.

Not that there's anything really wrong with W2003, the question is why
fix something that isn't broken, especially at Microsoft prices?

-- 
Joe


Relevant Pages

  • Re: Future of IT in Lebanon
    ... It's the same Linux code base. ... Microsoft Office on a Windows server, it will install and run fine, the main ...
    (soc.culture.lebanon)
  • RE: Printing from Win9x clients stops
    ... Open Server Management. ... then right-click the name of the computer running Windows Small Business ... >From the client computer: ... The Select Network Component Type ...
    (microsoft.public.windows.server.sbs)
  • Re: Question about Red Hat Linux Enterprise
    ... we have is running Windows 2000 Server ... Luckily running Apache + MySQL on a Linux system is not a lot ... MySQL database and injecting it back into the MySQL installation ...
    (comp.os.linux.networking)
  • Re: Sweet Success
    ... Let's continue to assume that I prefer Windows to anything else: ... neither Linux nor Windows may be the answer. ... While it may well be initially less expensive to install a Linux-based ... of Linux simultaneously, along with Windows Server, AIX, and OS/400. ...
    (RedHat)
  • Re: [Full-disclosure] 70 million computers are using Windows 98 right now
    ... Linux is definitely not a natural migration pathway. ... Windows 2000, Windows XP, and Mac OS X seem to work pretty ... > desktop to server. ... But then the persons across the sea just can't install ...
    (Full-Disclosure)