Re: Anybody using a "real" Linux domain?

From: David (dwmoar_at_findmoore.net)
Date: 05/27/05


Date: Fri, 27 May 2005 10:06:48 -0700

Alan Connor wrote:
> On comp.os.linux.misc, in
> <pan.2005.05.26.23.25.53.167285@hooya.moc>, "Bill Davis" wrote:
>
>
>>This is not a request for a cookbook answer of "How do I ...?"
>>I am just wanting insights from folks who may have done the
>>following.
>>
>>I assist the full time techie at a fairly small school
>>district, part time. They have 99% windows desktops, 5 Novell
>>servers and a coupla of windows 200x servers.
>>
>>Due to some disguntled vendors, the school board (all of whom
>>are definitely NON-techie) has been convinced by the local
>>legal staff (all one of them) that Microsoft is right in their
>>claim that a windows license is only good for the machine that
>>it was sold for. That is, if you throw the machine away, you
>>also have to throw the license away.

If you read the MS EULA you will find that information in there. MS
wants you to beleive that the license is only good for the machine that
the os was purchased for and if you toss that machine you would have to
purchase andother license for the replacement machine.

>>
>>To me that is total BS.

Yes it may be total BS but this is what is in the EULA. If one doesn't
agree with the EULA than perhaps they shouldn't use MS. (Not a bad idea
IMO anyway)

If I buy a refrigerator for my house,
>>then later move to another, can Sears say that I have to leave
>>the box behind and purchase another one for my new house
>>because the "license" for that icebox is only good for the
>>place to which it was originally delivered? Not as long as
>>Texas allows the ownership of shotguns, it doesn't. I have
>>pointed out that we have a documented legal license for every
>>PC that windows is installed on.

yes, and it say that the OS is good for only the machine it was
purchased and licensed on!

   However, board members don't
>>put legal advice from a techie over that from a lawyer.
>>
>>But, there is a good side to the above crap. Since we can
>>either buy textbooks or new windows licenses, the textbooks won
>>out and we have to find a cheaper way of doing business. Guess
>>with what?
>>
>>We have been gradually installing Linux in areas where a single
>>function can be identifed and removing that function from
>>whatever Winbox it was on. Such as our Proxy and Surf filter
>>(That saves over nine thousand dollars a year), firewalls,
>>SANs, programming labs, web server, etc. The process has
>>been slow enough that we can take our time and make sure that
>>the new solution works as good or better than the one it
>>replaced. Desktops have to wait till be handle the servers.
>>But everything that has gone before can almost be considered to
>>be standalone applications.
>>
>>Now it is time to plan for the next big leap. Replacing the
>>Novell and MS server domain that covers the 5 campuses. No
>>small thing, because Novell does a lot and it does it well and
>>it does it without worms and viruses and 5 critical patches
>>a week. I have been researching domains using SMB, LDAP,
>>Kerberos, etc, etc, and obviously Linux will do the same
>>thing - I am just not sure how well. In our Novell books and
>>docs, domain management is the bulk of the text. For Linux,
>>domains are mentioned in a couple of paragraphs at the end of a
>>miscellaneous chapter. The few LDAP books I have found are too
>>vague to help much and are unsatisfactory.
>>
>>So, anybody out there driving a one-logon Linux domain, as
>>opposed to just a bunch of servers? I would like to know your
>>opinions along with what you are using.
>>
>>Thanks Bill Davis
>
>
> I suggest that you contact the nearest LUG. They always run
> very complete Linux domains. Get on their mailing list.
>
> You will probably find your school overrun with eager Linux
> geeks that'll have your domain up and running in a week!
>
> :-)
>
> AC
>
>



Relevant Pages

  • Re: Anybody using a "real" Linux domain?
    ... >>servers and a coupla of windows 200x servers. ... >>also have to throw the license away. ... purchase andother license for the replacement machine. ... >>We have been gradually installing Linux in areas where a single ...
    (comp.os.linux.networking)
  • Anybody using a "real" Linux domain?
    ... windows 200x servers. ... you also have to throw the license away. ... We have been gradually installing Linux in areas where a single function ...
    (comp.os.linux.misc)
  • Re: Delphi vs Web/Scripting Languages
    ... This is just rubbish - its propoganda disseminated by Microsoft to stop people using Linux. ... The fact is that most web servers *are* linux and servers is where the big boys play. ... Corporations will of course purchase products to run on Linux servers, but for the common Linux user they are used to using just about everything for free and will hesitate big time before purchasing a commercial desktop GUI type utility application etc. ... Microsoft propaganda has nothing to do with it, and if the free stuff is "Good Enough", they will not shell out any cash, even if the product is fairly priced. ...
    (borland.public.delphi.non-technical)
  • Re: Delphi vs Web/Scripting Languages
    ... This is just rubbish - its propoganda disseminated by Microsoft to stop people using Linux. ... The fact is that most web servers *are* linux and servers is where the big boys play. ... Corporations will of course purchase products to run on Linux servers, but for the common Linux user they are used to using just about everything for free and will hesitate big time before purchasing a commercial desktop GUI type utility application etc. ... Microsoft propaganda has nothing to do with it, and if the free stuff is "Good Enough", they will not shell out any cash, even if the product is fairly priced. ...
    (borland.public.delphi.non-technical)
  • Re: SBS Licensing Problems
    ... "Indicates that changes to license purchase information ... configure licensing on my servers from scratch. ... CPL.CFG file per the instructions in article 153140 isn't always the way to ...
    (microsoft.public.windows.server.sbs)