Re: Convert wma to mp3?



On a similar note, is AAC(HE-AAC,mp4) patentend in a similar manner,
restricting people from encoding/decoding without paying for patent? I
found 3 paragraphs about this in wikipedia(http://en.wikipedia.org/
wiki/Advanced_Audio_Coding#Licensing_and_patents) and I find all the 3
paragraphs dis-agree each other. I want to encode my music to AAC,
anyone know of these patent issues?

On Apr 26, 6:51 am, Unruh <unruh-s...@xxxxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote:
A Watcher <stocks...@xxxxxxxxxxxxx> writes:
Is there a linux app that will convert wma files to mp3?

a) MP3 is a proprietary patented format at least in the USA and the
holders do NOT allow people to use the patent for encoding via mp3. That
was one of the key reasons why OggVobis encoding was developed.
Thus if you are in one of ht ecountries where mp3 is patented, you would be
violating their patent and in particular the distributions would be
violating the patent by distributing code which did that without paying the
requested patent fee.

b) That being said, people living in countries where mp3 is not patented
have developed mp3 encoding software-- the one I know of is called lame.
(Lame Ain't MP3 Encoder)
No distribution can distribute it-- see above. But people have placed it
onto databases in countries where the patent does not apply. YOur using
that software in a country where the patent does apply may make you liable
to a patent infringement suit or even criminal prosecution in places where
patent infringement is a criminal act. Of course they have to first
discover that you did it first. Now that you have published your desire to
do so on the internet where all 8 billion people in the world can see that
you have that desire, that discovery may not be hard, or it may be.

Thanks


.



Relevant Pages

  • Re: Convert wma to mp3?
    ... holders do NOT allow people to use the patent for encoding via mp3. ... You'd better tell that to the authors of the ISO standard, ...
    (comp.os.linux.misc)
  • Re: Convert wma to mp3?
    ... holders do NOT allow people to use the patent for encoding via mp3. ... Thus if you are in one of ht ecountries where mp3 is patented, ... onto databases in countries where the patent does not apply. ...
    (comp.os.linux.misc)
  • Re: Software Patents
    ... >>> This is actually an argument used by patent advocates. ... >> Well, that works for LZW, but what about Arithmetic Encoding? ... IBM has managed to patent a method which is ... is exactly how AE is better than Huffman encoding. ...
    (comp.programming)
  • Re: 90degree phase shifts
    ... noise-reduction encoding. ... Dolby could not patent the surround ... or Type B, depending on the release format), which Ultra Stereo had to mimic ... The Ultra Stereo decoders did the matrix properly (and Dolby could ...
    (rec.audio.pro)
  • Re: Are EPIC and Mill really VLIWs?
    ... The Mill encoding does not have units ... of encoding that comprise more than one unit of issue in the EPIC style. ... encoding for each unit of issue, whereas classic VLIW has exactly one. ... This was an idea that IMHO was absolutely worthy of a patent... ...
    (comp.arch)