Re: Vista to Unix



On Wed, 27 Feb 2008 16:00:26 -0800, Jeffrey Drake wrote:

I am considering a move from Vista to a Unix-variant on my laptop. I
have been quite happy with my vista install with a few nagging
exceptions. It is those exceptions that cause me to look elsewhere.

I have used Ubuntu (7.10) on this laptop before, and I have been quite
displeased about its shoddy wireless networking and ACPI sleep support.
It was often that the wireless networking would simply NOT work after
waking up. Also, sometimes the sleep function would essentially freeze
the machine before it even went to sleep.

What I am looking for is something to solve those problems primarily. I
am willing to consider FreeBSD 7, Slackware, or even Fedora if it is
reasonably better than Ubuntu in this regard.

I do not care for NetworkManager, as the version included with 7.10
seemed to be an attempt to produce something that Windows does fairly
well, but make it actually suck.

My laptop is an Acer Aspire 5570, it uses Intel's video and wireless, I
believe it is a 945 based chipset, but I am not 100% sure on this.

Any thoughts on this matter would be appreciated.

With Regards,
Jeffrey Drake.

Try Fedora 8, the wireless networking works pretty well with Intel WiFI.
Sleep support is an area where Linux is fairly weak, it's a kernel
problem not a distro problem. Fedora 8 uses the latest kernel so it has
the best chance of working. I don't know which kernel Ubuntu is using
now, if it's a 2.6.23 kernel then Fedora isn't likely to work any better,
if it's 2.6.22 then F8 should be better.
.



Relevant Pages

  • Feisty and RT2500 Wifi card
    ... I am new Ubuntu user (I switched over from Fedora) and have a question ... It uses the 2.6.20 kernel which I believe ... Has anyone confirmed whether the R2500 driver will work with Feisty. ... I'm pretty glad I moved over to Ubuntu. ...
    (Ubuntu)
  • Re: Fedora philosophy (was ATI video comes out of the closet)
    ... Having done significant testing on Ubuntu (primarily because of the superior ... kernel interfaces, Ubuntu suffers the same fate as Fedora does. ... release notes and changelog isn't even enough for some of these patches; ...
    (Fedora)
  • Re: Fedora philosophy (was ATI video comes out of the closet)
    ... software repository and lack of the 'mixing' issues), and having done some support of 'ordinary' users on Ubuntu, let me say this: when it comes to the kernel interfaces, Ubuntu suffers the same fate as Fedora does. ... The kernel interface issue is upstream, and any distribution tracking 2.6 is going to have unstable kernel API's. ... It is not a Fedora disease; it is a kernel development process disease, ... release notes and changelog isn't even enough for some of these patches; one must in some cases track the actual source RPM patchsets and changes, ...
    (Fedora)
  • Re: Ubuntu 1, Fedora 0
    ... and it worked like perfectly on the 4 machines I tried it on. ... this is what is called a stable Version of Ubuntu. ... as many people report problems installing Fedora this way. ... Fedora comes out with a kernel update more often the other distro's, ...
    (Fedora)
  • [Full-disclosure] [USN-302-1] Linux kernel vulnerabilities
    ... A security issue affects the following Ubuntu releases: ... Due to an unavoidable ABI change the Ubuntu 6.06 kernel ... a remote attacker could exploit this to trigger a buffer ... amd64 architecture ...
    (Full-Disclosure)