Re: Floppies read by Windows but not by Linux

On 11/01/2011 23:08, Robert Heller wrote:
At Tue, 11 Jan 2011 22:08:17 +0100 Rikishi42<skunkworks@xxxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote:


On 2011-01-11, Charles Packer<mailbox@xxxxxxxxxxx> wrote:
Why can some of my older floppies, newly written on with
my vintage Sony Mavica camera, be read by Windows XP but
not by Linux? All I know at this point is that formatting
is not at issue.

Maybe they're formatted in FAT16, rather than FAT32 ?

True floppies (eg 1.44Mbyte) are normally formatted FAT12. FAT16 was
for larger media, like Zip disks (100, 150, 250 mbytes).


I seem to recall reading a case in which that FAT16 was supported, but
wasn't one of the format that the automated mounting would use.

Linux does not work like that: there is fat, vfat, and msdos at the FS
level. Where it is 12 bit, 16 bit or 32 bit pointers happens at a lower
level (when what passes a super-block is read at mount time).


Try to mount it manually, using FAT16 as type.

Under mount options for fat, vfat, and msdos:

fat=12 / fat=16 / fat=32
Specify a 12, 16 or 32 bit fat. This overrides the automatic
FAT type detection routine. Use with caution!

Also, check the type in Windows, asking for the properties of the floppy.


If it is (for some odd reason) NTFS, that would be different and yes,
most linux kernels don't include full support (if at all) for NTFS.


Most modern distros support NTFS out of the box (perhaps read-only by default automatic identification, requiring an explicit fs type for read-write). However, NTFS won't fit on a floppy - the basic fs structures are too big.

.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: NTFS Concerns with FC2
    ... >> and reading it using Fedora Core 2, ... > If that's the direction you need to go, then don't worry about NTFS ... formatted by Linux, Windows XP wants to start formatting it. ...
    (Fedora)
  • Re: What after XP?
    ... Although NTFS has the necessary features for UAC, sadly, the OS, being ... the users' favour rather than to the favour of malware exploits. ... you have to remember that Linux still didn't have ... Don't forget that it wasn't really practical to run most windows ...
    (uk.comp.homebuilt)
  • Re: Crossover / Wine cannot install Office
    ... There will never be a Linux equivalent of Access, ... but the issue is always compatibility with other businesses ... There's good exchange with OO, ... >The formatting might not be exactly right, or the fonts might be off. ...
    (comp.os.linux.misc)
  • Re: Basic structure of Linux : File system, types of files with extentions, drive informations, and
    ... of R/W NTFS with Linux: ... Linux is not generally expected to be able ... Afaik it is the the 'partition' which is formatted, ... ntfs harddrive into a linux folder, format the external harddrive as ...
    (alt.os.linux)
  • Re: Linux for Network Attached Storage?
    ... >>response the person helping him pointed out who is the one lost. ... Linux will not do what you asked for, ... >>This war makes it difficult to support NTFS, ... >>If your requirement is a file server that sits on an NTFS disk your best ...
    (alt.os.linux.redhat)