Can LILO do this too?



Having grub setup to boot from a CompactFlash,
and then plugging eg. a USB disk before you boot,
means that the CF may change from being /dev/sdb,
to being /dev/sdc,
because the USB disk gets 'allocated in front of'
the CF -- apparently.

With grub, you can just 'live edit' the immediately
visible menu, from sdb to sdc.

Besides grub can access a device via its LABEL;
so it doesn't matter <where the device is located>.

What do you do if you've got LILO instead?!

How is it possible that a 'knl2.4 grub' can see
a knl2.4 originated ext2, but can't see a
knl2.6 originated ext2 ?

Since grub has got the various FS-drivers: ext2, ext3, js*,
one can understand that it couldn't read an ext3 if the
driver was missing; but aren't ALL ext2 equal, independant
of the kernel-version that created them?
What about different inode sizes, can grub handle all?

Of course, it's nice with grub: it shows you what IT can see,
because even before the OS has booted, grub can effectively
do a <fdisk -l>. But with LILO, you are in the dark.

The <old>-grub has some quirks.
Is it worth getting grub-2 -- for distributions designed for LILO?

I've got a little-known-slak-based distribution CD, which allows
<editing of the knl, initrd, vga ..etc> before booting, which seems
nice; but I'm confused, because I thought this distribution used LILO.
What does the <syslinux> system do?

== TIA

.



Relevant Pages

  • Re: Can LILO do this too?
    ... and then plugging eg. a USB disk before you boot, ... Besides grub can access a device via its LABEL; ... What do you do if you've got LILO instead?! ... knl2.6 originated ext2? ...
    (comp.os.linux.misc)
  • Re: Why cant ext4 file systems be used as a boot partition?
    ... GRUB option, that a logical drive shall be booted in the ... "traditional" (LILO) way? ... then be the Windows bootloader. ... the first boot stage must be invoked by the BIOS. ...
    (comp.os.linux.setup)
  • Re: Why all the futzing with boot loaders
    ... Now apt-get dist-upgrade _removes_ a working GRUB and installs a non-working LILO; ... There are a few situations, if I recall correctly, where lilo worked but grub didn't. ... IMHO, grub is a HUGE improvement over lilo, because you can have multiple boot options configured simultaneously, so if you screw up a new kernel install, you can always boot from the old one. ... Secondary loader: 19 sectors. ...
    (Debian-User)
  • Re: lilo removal in squeeze (or, "please test grub2")
    ... In what way is it a vast improvement over LILO? ... how exactly would grub be a better choice for me? ... I frequently roll new kernels from kernel.org source using the Debian ... If something goes wrong converting from LILO to Grub2, ...
    (Debian-User)
  • Re: lilo removal in squeeze (or, "please test grub2")
    ... In what way is it a vast improvement over LILO? ... how exactly would grub be a better choice for me? ... If something goes wrong converting from LILO to Grub2, ... custom kernel to grub rather than lilo should affect your kernel ...
    (Debian-User)