Re: grub menu oddity




Richard wrote:
> I have a multi-boot system using grub installed in the mbr of my first hd.
> It seems like every time my motherboard bios updates its configuration data
> (such as after changing a video card), grub refuses to boot from any menu
> selection (I think the message is Error 18). However, if I drop to a
> command line and manually execute the root command for any menu item, I can
> then go back to the menu and boot normally. All subsequent boots are
> normal. The manual root command is exactly the same as the root command in
> menu.lst. Anyone know why the root commands executed via the menu are
> rejected but the same command executed via the command line is accepted?
>
> Thanks
> Richard

hi;
I am very curious as well - perhaps a few more questions may help
Enrique and others, much more knowledgeable about linux than I, figure
this out for you;

-- How many OSes are in your Multi-Boot array ?
-- How Many HDDs ?
-- Any PCI IDE Controller Cards installed or SCSI Adapter Cards ?
-- Any RAID arrays ?
-- System Mobo make/model ?
-- BIOS type and version (Award, Pheonix, AMI, etc)

If there is more than 1 version/copy of grub somewhere else on your
HDDs, is it possible that that 'other' copy is being used after BIOS
config changes ? More-so, is it possible there's a Symbolic link
somewhere that's pointing to a different kernel, or updated kernel ?

There can be issues with the way grub sees the various default linux
numbering scheme, as I've found from reading previous info posted by
Enrique.

>>From the info you've posted, it would certainly seem there's some sort
of issue with the CMOS NVRAM area (nowadays, the NVRAM/RTC is
integrated into the South Bridge itself) and the storage of the changes
made there-in.

Possible a setting in the BIOS is set to Auto "Load Setup Defaults"
after saving changes ? There's usually options to "Save Custom
Defaults" - and "Load Custom Defaults" -- curious what the options you
have.

Have you ever Flashed (updated) the Motherboard BIOS ROM ?

Another quick thought is the CMOS battery is old and dying, though
other issues/problems as a consequence of this would be much more
prevelant.

.



Relevant Pages

  • Re: grub menu oddity
    ... It seems like every time my motherboard bios updates its configuration data, grub refuses to boot from any menu selection. ... However, if I drop to a command line and manually execute the root command for any menu item, I can then go back to the menu and boot normally. ...
    (comp.os.linux.setup)
  • Re: grub menu oddity
    ... >> I have a multi-boot system using grub installed in the mbr of my ... It seems like every time my motherboard bios updates its ... >> refuses to boot from any menu selection (I think the message is Error ... >> command is exactly the same as the root command in menu.lst. ...
    (comp.os.linux.setup)
  • Re: grub menu oddity
    ... >> BIOS version 4S4EB2X0.86A.0024.P17 ... >> command (until the manual root command was executed). ... boot without fail from a grub floppy with a menu.lst on the floppy. ...
    (comp.os.linux.setup)
  • Re: grub menu oddity
    ... >> I have a multi-boot system using grub installed in the mbr of my ... It seems like every time my motherboard bios updates its ... if I drop to a command line and manually execute the ... >> command is exactly the same as the root command in menu.lst. ...
    (comp.os.linux.setup)
  • Re: Grub hangs - two hard drives and a CD
    ... I don't know if there is any way that the Linux ... the Bios tries to boot off different devices. ... If you can find out what disk the bios is accessing, ... If it is a grub "stage1" sector, ...
    (comp.os.linux.setup)