Re: Is there a distribution that has NTFS writing turned on by default?



On Fri, 14 Apr 2006 18:56:50 -0400, Chris F Clark wrote:

I'm currently running dual-boot CentOS 4.1/XP on my laptop. I have a
2nd laptop that I would like to set up similarly (but better). One of
the things I would like is a distro that can read/write NTFS
natively--I know the support is experimental to some people, but I
don't care. However, I have no interest in configuring and/or
compiling a kernel myself. I would like to get one configured "right"
out of the box.

What I want is:

X support (I don't care between gnome and kde as I have my own
WM and use it mostly to get me into emacs, which is also my
own version).

NTFS

ext2 support (I'm not certain on SELinux as I can't use
Partition Magic to copy/resize partitions written under
CentOS--I haven't resolved that issue yet. I think ACLs are
the problem. I know I don't wan't ReiserFS or ext3
partitions. I want vanilla backward-compatible partitions. I
wouldn't even want NTFS, but that's how I've got XP working
and converting NTFS to FAT32 breaks my installation, so I
*need* NTFS.)

Nice to have:

Top-notch easy-to-use Java and Mono support

Easy to use WLAN support

Note both laptops are approximately the same (i.e. IBM thinkpad a30p,
but different actual models so the graphics drivers etc. are not
identical). In the end I want to swap the disk between the two
systems and have it just boot on which ever laptop it is plugged
into--and then, I'll clone two copies of the disk and I'll have a
running system and a hot-spare.

It will work with GNU/Linux, but it might not boot with Windows (see
first link below.)


I've got XP running so I can do that today. (Yes, I have the requisite
licenses for XP et. al. on both machines.) However, because the disk I
want to move the software to is a slightly different geometry than the
disk I am moving from I need to resize the partitions when I move them
and neither gnuparted nor partition magic like the partitions CentOS has
written. (Note if it weren't for the partition issue, I would be
parfectly happy with CentOS.)

Backup using standard tools (tar, ntfsclone), possibly using a network
transport.


Therefore, I figure I'll install a new OS (on the 2nd system) from
scratch, one I can use the partitioning tools on. Then, I'll copy my
user data over (using tar). Then, I'll clone using the partitioning
tools, that system to the other disk (for the 1st system).

ntfsclone is good for this sort of operation. Also works with virtual
machines, too. I wrote this earlier today (about moving Windows to new
hardware, could be new "virtual hardware."):
http://groups.google.com/group/alt.os.linux.mandriva/msg/0a3063844990fba6



Any advice appreciated, thanks,
-Chris

There have been recent advances in the NTFS project, and it seems to be
gaining momentum again, as shown by their new wiki for ntfsmount:
http://wiki.linux-ntfs.org/doku.php?id=ntfsmount

I still think if you want direct access to your entire Windows box
(capable of running Windows apps) then VMWare is the best choice.

This includes three links about vmware:
http://groups.google.com/group/comp.os.linux.advocacy/msg/fecd6ad386d8c597

--
Douglas Mayne
.



Relevant Pages

  • Re: RH and NTFS
    ... Do I have to convert every disk or only the disk ... > disks NTFS and have to convert one disk only and can read this when I ... when you install linux you will need to create your linux partitions from ...
    (alt.linux)
  • RE: Lost access after cloning disk.
    ... systems that were not deployed following the support Microsoft process. ... 298491 How To Use the System Preparation Tool to Perform Disk ... Microsoft Online Support ... | disk clone and all the partitions show up with the correct drive letters. ...
    (microsoft.public.windows.file_system)
  • Re: FAT32 Vs. NTFS
    ... I was reading this post back in september because that's when I got my ACER ... partitions, as this is performed at your own discretion. ... The size of the partitions drives will not always add up to the total size ... drive to NTFS. ...
    (microsoft.public.windowsxp.basics)
  • Re: Space Constrained HD - SBS SP1 size concern
    ... appear as seperate disks and not partitions. ... obstacle or if the sofware accomodates disk management like this. ... >>> reserve the right to refuse support of systems with partitions adjusted ...
    (microsoft.public.windows.server.sbs)
  • Re: RH and NTFS
    ... >> disks NTFS and have to convert one disk only and can read this when I ... > when you install linux you will need to create your linux partitions from ...
    (alt.linux)