Re: installation puzzle



In message <%bCrh.2466$jG1.82@trnddc04>
"Ben Crain" <bcrain@xxxxxxxxxxx> wrote:

I finally decide to try Linux -- via the distribution that comes with the
book "Suse Linux 10 Unleashed" (by Michael McCallister). My current setup:
running Windows XP, with two hard drives in a RAID configuration, and also a
separate third hard drive (or, really, second hard drive, since the two RAID
drives are functionally just one). I try to install Linux from the DVD that
comes with the book, and soon get an error message that says something like
(I paraphrase): "A harddrive is detected with a RAID configuration which
the BIOS says is a hardware RAID but it's really a software RAID". (I
swear, that's what the message said!) "If you install Linux on that
harddrive it will destroy the RAID".

But I was planning to install Linux on the separate harddrive which has no
RAID configuration, so I just ignored that message and proceeded. By
selecting "Custom Partionining", or whatever it was called, I got to the
point of being able to designate that Linux would be installed on my second,
separate, non-RAID-infested harddrive. It then began the base installation,
which seemed to proceed smoothly. According to the book, after the base
installation it would proceed to the task of "Creating the root User". But,
what actually happened: it acted as though the computer were being
re-booted, and showed the Suse installation setup screen once again (though
this time with more colors). But not for long: while I was staring at it
trying to figure out what was going on, that screen vanished and WinXP
booted normally. I then removed the Linux DVD and rebooted, and it just
goes directly to WinXP, which operates normally. Except it can't access
that second drive, which, according to PartitionMagic, has indeed been
formatted for Linux.

But the book says (pg 36): "If YaST detects the presence of another
operating system, it will ask whether you want to replace that OS with SUSE
Linux or dual boot both." Yes, I do want to dual boot, but it never asked
me that. Perhaps it would have after the base installation, but instead it
re-booted itself into Windows.

I did try installing anew, and everything proceeded as above (with the same
error messages about RAID), until at some point in the base installation the
entire system froze. No mouse movement, no nothing. So I shut down the pc
and gave up on this installation. Any ideas?

I'm no expert. However, based on what I've read, the way it arranges
dual boot is that it replaces the Windows "startup" on the primary
drive with one which launches Grub. Grub is automatically configured
to offer a choice between Liunux and Windows.

Now this means altering the MBR of the primary drive, which it has
already decided is a RAID configuration it doesn't know how to touch.
I'm not surprised it hasn't altered the boot setting.

I *think* there is a way to make the Windows boot loader offer Linux -
it will involve editing BOOT.INI, but I don't know the details. That
would be an alternative for you.

Alan

--
Alan Adams, from Northamptonshire
alan.adams@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
http://www.nckc.org.uk/
.



Relevant Pages

  • New System planning -- Summary
    ... >To build a system that to run Linux (probably Ubuntu or Kubuntu, ... > Flat Panel monitor, Make? ... You want huge hard drives with 16 MB buffers. ... Two fast 160 GB drives will work, but not RAID, one 250 MB drive is cheaper. ...
    (Ubuntu)
  • Re: IRQ Conflict problems Promise TX2000 RAID, Asus A7M266-D
    ... -1- Start the installation as you've been doing by entering "linux ... 17 of "Linux RAID HOWTO" by Murty Rompalli. ... Notice that the PDC20276 has only one IRQ from the line "RAID bus ... > Having real problems trying to get a Promise TX2000 RAID controller card ...
    (comp.os.linux.hardware)
  • Re: Problem with software-raid/lvm after reinstallation (2.6)
    ... my old installation, and I had a bit of problems. ... installed and restore from the backups you made prior to the reinstall. ... have incompatibilities between Sid and Etch: md raid, lvm, ext. ... If the drives have S.M.A.R.T. ...
    (Debian-User)
  • Re: Storage for the home user.
    ... Be sure to put the OS and SWAP file and a DIFFERENT drive/set of drives than the drives used to store the data. ... While OS corruptions and crashes don't happen often on Linux, ... I attached a tape library to the server via a SCSI card and backup from the local RAID to the tape. ...
    (comp.arch.storage)
  • RE: SATA RAID Array and Windows reload
    ... I'm not trying to load Windows onto my RAID array, ... RAID array for data. ... I did install the nVidia drivers from Windows after installation. ... > 1st,you must remove all drives except the RAID set and cdrom during ...
    (microsoft.public.windowsxp.hardware)