Re: DualScreen, 2 cards, AGP and PCI, have to boot from PCI?

From: Craig Bergren (cbergren_at_tvbox.bergren.us)
Date: 08/28/04


Date: Sat, 28 Aug 2004 18:43:24 GMT

On Sat, 28 Aug 2004 11:32:38 +0200, Dieter Soltau wrote:

> hi Craig,
>
>> Dieter, Ich denke, daß Floyd ein wenig verwechselt wird.
> say what <g>? "verwechselt" does mean, "taken for someone else". you sure
> you eanted to say this? ;)

Damn babelfish, I was going to use falsch, but I wanted to sound more
sophisticated.

>
>> a) set your BIOS to use the AGP card for primary video controller. b)
>> modify the virtual console driver to use non-BIOS VGA (your AGP card).
> hmm, dunno how i should handle b), though..
>
>>> it uses the AGP and i see nothing on the PCI card.
>>>
>>>> BusID "PCI:00:14:00"
>>>> BusID "PCI:00:13:00"
>>>

> and PCI card at 0:11.0 !!! lspci shows it fine, but *I* see nothing on
> the *monitor*. the PCI card is simply not initialized or whatever. pci
> card monitorLED keeps flashing. there is no input from the card.

This indicates to me that the BIOS isn't initializing the card, perhaps we
can get X to do this for you.
 
>> Scenario 2: PCI is set for VGA in BIOS. lspci shows both AGP card at
>> 1:0.0
>> and PCI card at 0:11.0
>>
>> You may want to try moving the PCI card to a different slot. It
>> appears to affect the way the cards are interpreted when scanned by the
>> BIOS.

> am i correct that you misunderstood me, and thought lspci woudnt see the
> card, or should i change slots anyway? dunno what i could get except a
> different number, 0:9:0 or whatever? or *should* the pci card become
> 1:0:0? is this the goal? anyway - booting from PCI will not bet me
> further, i guess we all agree on this..

You may still want to try changing slots, it couldn't hurt. If you read
the link I sent you, you will see that the some BIOSes make assumptions
about the cards by their position on the bus. Perhaps the BIOS assumes
any PCI video card in slot 11 is the primary.

>
> i try to summarize this again:
>
> if i connect my AGP only, EVERYTHING is working as expected. no problems
> whatsoever.
>
> if i add my PCI card, BOTH are seen. AGP 1:0:0, PCI 0:b:0. if i boot
> from AGP, i see the bootprocedure on the AGP, nothing on PCI. then X
> starts, i am still on AGP and see nothing on PCI. NOTHING, not in
> normal, not in xinerama mode! now i press ALT-F1 to get a tty, and this
> is NOWHERE. not on my AGP and neither on my PCI. i press ALT-F7 again,
> and X is back on AGP.

What happens when you boot ohne X? Run level 3, vielicht?

>
> now, if i boot from PCI then everything is correct. bootprocedure starts
> from PCI. X starts - both monitors. i press ALT-F1 and it is shown on
> PCI (sure, i booted rom that card). X remains on AGP. this is fully
> correct to me, except that it is an ld card i dislike to use at primary.
> its a voodoo banshee, dont even know if it does 1600x1200 if i would
> keep that as primary.
>
> well, i hope this gets a bit clearer now? here some more parts of my
> xconf (fonts etc.. wiped out so it doesnt get to much). [0] is my AGP
> and 19", [1] is my PCI and 17":
>

Alles klar.

Is there anything interesting the the /var/log/Xorg.* logs?



Relevant Pages

  • Re: Boot from Sil-3112 controller when theres another
    ... PCI host card. ... The mainboard BIOS ... Both SCSI drives do not appear together in either the BIOS hard drive ...
    (alt.comp.hardware.pc-homebuilt)
  • Re: Boot from Sil-3112 controller when theres another
    ... PCI host card. ... The mainboard BIOS ... Don't SATA drives support hot swapping? ...
    (alt.comp.hardware.pc-homebuilt)
  • Re: external eSata enclosure drive recognition?
    ... I do have a PCI and PCI Express slot available. ... I know it has the ICH9 controller, at least, and NOT the newer ICH9R, ... As it is now, the Dell BIOS ... A separate card can be used two ways. ...
    (microsoft.public.windowsxp.hardware)
  • Re: Adaptec 2940U irq problem
    ... system bios for the scsi card but it doesn't seem to have any effect. ... The Adaptec 2940U is a PCI card. ... Windows applet like Device Manager. ...
    (comp.periphs.scsi)
  • Re: USB flash drives and graphics cards
    ... got no idea what it is but it seems that her existing graphics card isn't ... I think she currently has some sort of AGP card in her machine but can ... Fortunately, the FX5200 is available in AGP and PCI versions, so if there ...
    (microsoft.public.windowsxp.hardware)